To celebrate the return of Twin Peaks after a twenty-five year hiatus, I wanted to dip into
the exotic, surreal pool of David Lynch films.
Obviously, the most appropriate film for the occasion would be TWIN
PEAKS: FIRE WALK WITH ME, but that might be a little too on the nose. Also, it only came to me just now as I was
writing this, and I already made a bunch of notes about a different movie, so
I’m sticking with that one. It turns out
that might be an even more appropriate choice, though, because Lynch’s 1986
masterpiece BLUE VELVET could be thought of as his proto-Twin Peaks.
The Capsule:
When Jeffrey Beaumont (Kyle MacLachlan) returns to his
quaint hometown of Lumberton due to a family emergency, the discovery of a
human ear in a field sends him on a dark and increasingly dangerous journey
into the corruption hiding just underneath the town’s friendly surface. His desire to help a desperate and alluring
singer, Dorothy Vallens (Isabella Rossellini), sets the innocent young man on a
collision course with the abusive, explosively psychotic hoodlum Frank Booth
(Dennis Hopper). Sandy (Laura Dern), the
sweet, innocent police detective’s daughter, becomes Jeffrey’s only connection
to the light, and the one person who can save him from disappearing completely
into the town’s seedy underworld.
BLUE VELVET wasn’t my first introduction to David
Lynch. That would be DUNE, the doomed
sci-fi epic that I saw too young to understand but fell completely in love with
none the less. I had also seen his more
traditional drama THE ELEPHANT MAN, which had far fewer spaceships and giant
worms, but still captivated me. As much
as I liked those movies, they did not prepare me for BLUE VELVET. It was like nothing I had ever seen, both
beautiful and transgressive. Like many
people developing their taste for strange, BLUE VELVET was the perfect gateway
drug.
I’ve seen the movie at least a dozen times, but this was the
first time I completely keyed in to how much it could be considered a dry run
for Twin Peaks (or Twin Peaks as an extension of BLUE VELVET;
however you want to say it). Lumberton
does not look particularly Northwestern (the movie was filmed in North
Carolina), but it shares the same heavy lumber town motif central to Twin
Peaks. They also share a quality of
being stuck in time, specifically the ‘50s, even though they take place in the
present day. Both towns cover their dark
secrets under a layer of bright, law abiding hospitality. They have matching diners (Arlene’s in BLUE
VELVET, The Double R in Twin Peaks)
where the kids meet for exposition and devising plans. Each one has a smoky bar where an enchanting
torch singer performs.
Many of the hallmark touches Lynch would use in Twin Peaks are on display here. There are the hallucinatory dreams, the moments of melodrama, the quirky humor. No dancing dwarves, but someone does use a very unconvincing disguise. Not as unconvincing as Piper Laurie pretending to be an Asian man, but it's a start.
Many of the hallmark touches Lynch would use in Twin Peaks are on display here. There are the hallucinatory dreams, the moments of melodrama, the quirky humor. No dancing dwarves, but someone does use a very unconvincing disguise. Not as unconvincing as Piper Laurie pretending to be an Asian man, but it's a start.
BLUE VELVET’s characters have their Twin Peaks correlations as well.
Jeffrey Beaumont has the makings of a Junior Agent Dale Cooper. Once he catches hold of the mystery, he will
not let it go, regardless of the personal risk.
He has Cooper’s earnestness and curiosity. And while Cooper is a seasoned professional,
they both share the same excitement at uncovering secrets. When Jeffrey is explaining to Sandy what he
had learned while staking out Frank Booth, he proudly uses nicknames for
suspects like The Yellow Man, or The Well Dressed Man, exactly the way Agent
Cooper would.
Jeffrey’s first real encounter with the dark side
brilliantly twists the tone of the movie, going from innocent to uncomfortable
to completely fucked up within the space of a few minutes. He is still playing Hardy Boys when he sneaks
into Dorothy’s apartment looking for unspecific clues in the Case of the
Severed Ear. When the mysterious singer
unexpectedly returns home, Jeffrey hides in the closet. He watches her through the slats of the door
as she undresses, which is not very Boy Scout of him, in my opinion. Dorothy seems to agree, as she grabs a
butcher knife and pulls him from the closet.
The situation becomes more and more squirm inducing as she goes from
angrily interrogating him, to ordering him to strip, to practically raping him
at knife point. Things only get worse
once Frank shows up. Dorothy shoves
Jeffrey back into the closet where he has to watch Dennis Hopper give one of
the most disturbingly effective explosion of psychotic acting ever filmed.
Frank Booth is a live wire of menace. He is already on edge when he enters the room
because the meticulous script he imposes on Dorothy was not performed to the
letter (“Where’s my fucking bourbon?”). The
light has to be just so, she can’t say anything to him or touch him, and for
god’s sake, DO NOT LOOK AT HIM. Frank is
totally unhinged, and that is before he starts huffing from a canister of amyl
nitrite. Then all of Frank’s unhealthy
mommy issues come out.
Even though she is at no point dead and wrapped in plastic, Dorothy mirrors the tragic face of Twin Peaks',
Laura Palmer. Like Sheryl Lee’s
character, Dorothy is a victim of hideous forces beyond her control. Both women internalize all the abuse, sending
them farther down a twisted, self-destructive path. After
Booth’s assault, Jeffrey tries to help Dorothy, but she has no interest in being helped. Instead, she goes right back to seducing him as if nothing had happened. Her behavior vacillates between Booth’s
aggressive style and her own masochistic feelings of worthlessness. Jeffrey, being a fresh faced young horndog,
is happy to go along until she whispers “hit me” in his ear. At first Jeffrey reacts to this total boner
killing moment appropriately, but she keeps pressing the issue until he gives
in.
Jeffrey's attraction to
the dark side puts him at odds with Agent Cooper’s unbending morals, and makes
it harder to match him to any one person in Twin Peaks. Most of the younger characters dabble in
being bad to various degrees (Bobby, James, Audrey, Donna), but none perfectly capture both Jeffrey’s
weakness to temptation and his tortured guilt at being unable to resist. He
keeps going back to Dorothy, not to help get her out of her situation, but for
sex. She is obviously not in a rational
state of mind, saying things like “I have your disease in me now,” as if were
romantic rather than batshit crazy, but he keeps coming back.
Not that his illicit affair keeps him from also making time
with Sandy. The counter point to
Dorothy, Sandy is introduced emerging from darkness like a beam of light. She is the clear prototype for Lara Flynn
Boyle’s Donna in Twin Peaks, sweet, pure, and trusting. They even both have meathead football player boyfriends named Mike.
Jeffrey does his best to keep his two worlds separate, but
they collide in a spectacularly messy scene.
While taking Sandy back from a party, Jeffrey is chased home by a
speeding car. Jeffrey is relieved
when it turns out to be a drunk and jealous Mike intent on kicking his ass
rather than Frank Booth come to kill him, so much so that he completely throws Mike off his
game. He gets even more confused when
Dorothy, naked and beaten up, staggers into Jeffrey’s yard. He crudely asks Jeffrey “is that your mom,” but shuts up once he realizes the woman is hurt. All he can do is apologize as Jeffrey and
Sandy cover up Dorothy and get her into the car. I love that one of Mike’s moron friends
breaks the somber mood by complaining “I thought you were going to kill that guy.”
It really gets awkward when they get Dorothy back to Sandy’s
house. Dorothy keeps clutching onto
Jeffrey, calling him her secret lover and proudly telling Sandy and her mom, “I
have his disease in me,” as if it meant they were engaged or something. Understandably, Sandy doesn’t take it so well,
but later she forgives Jeffrey over the phone and tells him she loves him. Man, she should have twisted his balls a
little before taking him back. This is
more than being stood up at the dance, Sandy.
Make him grovel for pulling some shit like that.
Dennis Hopper makes Frank such a singular and unique
creation it’s hard to compare to anyone else, ever.
Frank Booth is the King Fuck of Psychos. If you had to match him to a Twin Peaks counterpart, he’s most like a combination of Eric DaRe’s abusive lowlife criminal Leo and the
chaotic malevolence of Bob (Frank Silva).
Not even a body hopping demon can hold a candle to Frank Booth,
though. He’s the type of guy you never
want to be noticed by. I get a pit in my
stomach the moment he locks his eyes on Jeffrey coming out of Dorothy’s
apartment. It’s like being spotted by a tiger,
but one that wants to fuck with you for a few hours before biting your head
off. With no way to refuse, Jeffrey gets
dragged into one of the most intensely nerve-wracking road trips in history.
One place you never, ever want to be is stuffed in a muscle
car between Raymond (Brad Dourif!) and Paul (Jack Nance, Pete from Twin
Peaks in a very different role), with Frank Booth at the wheel. It is a tense experience. Frank's toadies don't get many lines, but with faces like theirs, they don't need them.
Their first stop takes a turn towards the surreal when they
meet up with Ben (Dean Stockwell in his best role ever) a delicately suave
heroin junkie who runs the most depressing brothel ever. There's nobody quite like Ben in Twin Peaks. Ben is just Ben. At first he seems like he could be
sympathetic to Jeffrey’s dilemma since he appears to only be placating Frank for his own safety, but he turns out to be just another willing denizen of
Frank’s strange world. He sucker
punches Jeffrey in the stomach, just because he can. Then, in one of the most bizarre musical numbers ever, he entertains Frank by lip syncing a Roy
Orbison song into a work lamp until Frank’s mood swings and sends his entourage
back on the road.
Things come to a head when Jeffrey, unable to stomach Frank sexually
abusing Dorothy (while driving AND huffing gas), suddenly punches the lunatic
in the face. Everything screeches to a
halt and the cronies pull Jeffrey out of the car and hold him in front of
Frank, who is literally delirious with rage.
Thanks to Hopper’s performance, the scene transcends from simply suspenseful
to full out nightmare. The crossed wires
in Frank’s brain keep mixing up violence with attraction. One second he is threatening to shoot Jeffrey
in the head, the next he is smearing on lipstick and kissing the terrified kid
over and over on the mouth. Realistically we know the
hero won’t die in the middle of the movie, but aside from death (maybe?), all
bets are off.
Right in the middle of all this we get a beautifully Lynchian
moment. While Dorothy is in the car
screaming for Frank not to hurt Jeffrey, Frank demands someone put on the Roy Orbison
music again. As soon as the song starts
playing, the random hooker who tagged along from Ben’s place wordlessly gets
out of the car, climbs onto the roof and starts go-go dancing. No one acknowledges that this is happening. It is wonderful.
Jeffrey only winds up having the shit beat out of him, which
is the most he could have hoped for.
Especially since—as rumor has it—the original script had him waking up
in a field with his pants around his ankles.
Their final confrontation occurs in the place where they
first crossed paths. [Spoiler for a 31
year old movie] For all his unrestrained brutality, Frank still gets outplayed
by Jeffrey's quick thinking at the end. The look of shock
on Frank’s face when he realizes Jeffrey has the drop on him—the second before the
kid puts a bullet through his head—is priceless. Frank Booth’s exit is just as sudden and
violent as his entrance into the movie.
The final shot of the film is a symbolic image of good
triumphing (or eating) evil. Everything
is set right and life in the sun can continue.
The happy ending extended to Lynch as well. The movie’s success allowed the director to
bring us darker, stranger material, including expanding BLUE VELVET’s premise
into an entire television series, one which very much subverted its
predecessor’s tidy ending. Lynch learned
that just like Jeffrey, his audience had a fascination with the dangerous, sordid
world lying just under the cheerful surface.
We should thank him for allowing us to safely dig in.
As Frank would say (by way of Ben’s toast), “Here’s to your
fuck.”
C Chaka